opinions  
 
  topics  
 
  people  
 
  signup  
 
login | signup
 
  
Search
Add New Opinion
 

  People who have genetic disposition towards deadly diseases should not have children.
 
"Some willfully have children knowing that the risk is extremely high that the children will be disabled by terrible diseases. "
by Deah McNeill, 1 year ago
3293 voted, 45% agreed,
    
1045 comments

Ratings +8
Share
    
ask friends
  embed
category: Other
related topics: "Let's, see, how, this, one, flies."

 
comments
 
insights
 
who voted
 
 
  Add  
500 characters left |      
 
Show: newest first |  oldest first |  top rated
 
Showing 1 - 10 of 1046 Comments
 
   
 
 
  Lynette Pearce wrote 1 year ago
agree, if u know there is a very high risk, u shouldnt want to put a child through that .
agreed
   
+1
 
 
  hanny_26 wrote 1 year ago
They can adopt!
agreed
   
+1
 
 
  Olga Athana wrote 1 year ago
I think it is difficult to find an answer to that. On first thought it may seem too selfish of them to have children but on the other hand everyone else should put ourselves in their own position. We can't judge anyone's desire to have children. Also, one may say that they don't have the right to do this to their own children, but, on the other hand, it's their right to have their own children and try through them to give something better to the world.
   
+1
 
 
  Jason Loong wrote 1 year ago
Disposition implies probability, not absolutes.

To chance is to risk.
To risk is to hope over fear.
Where do you draw the line of hope, fear and preordained outcome ?

Deontological absolutes will invariably approve or dismiss it outright.
Change the probabilities to invalidate this, one might do.
   
+1
 
 
  Rajiv Iyer wrote 11 months ago
very loaded question on a very sensitive issue. Nonetheless, I agree. It may be hard to accept the notion of restricting one of the most fundamental of human urges - to propagate the variant of one's own self to a new young one, to care for it, to nurture it, to shower it with love and affection, to experience the reciprocation of feelings it offers you.
agreed
   
+1
 
 
  Rajiv Iyer wrote 11 months ago
part II: [Contd]: Yet given the question, we must examine the pain and suffering that the offspring would face - sooner or later. When faced with a diseases as deadly as AIDS/Cancer, how would its life be spent normally and happily? Would not the inevitability of its death depress both child and its parent? Wouldn't it be better to shower all your affection on an orphaned child by adopting it?
agreed
   
+1
 
 
  Sun wrote 10 months ago
Developed medical science could help them have healthy children.
disagreed
   
+1
 
 
  Whatshisface wrote 1 year ago
Can you give an example? Like with percentages and stuff? This is one of those "where do you draw the line?" things that are very difficult.
   
0
 
 
  Omar Luther King wrote 1 year ago
There should be no objection for those who are willing to being up handicap children cheerfully. There are some of that kind. Hats off to them.

OMAR
agreed
   
0
 
 
  Desu? wrote 1 year ago
Deadly diseases like life?
I totally agree.
agreed
   
0
 
 
 
<<previous 1 2 3 4 5 next>>
  quick links
   
followers
   
opinions
   
comments
   
notes received
   
replies
   
ratings

related opinions
Biological weapons (new deadly diseases) are still being manufactured.
25 voted, 16 comments
Aborted children should be used for genetic research.
203 voted, 12 comments
Marriage of relatives can bring up hidden genetic diseases.
42 voted, 12 comments
I don't understand homosexuality (is it learned behavior or genetic pre-disposition?) ...
23 voted, 8 comments
People who have genetic disposition towards deadly religions should not have ...
49 voted, 7 comments
People who have serious genetic defects or diseases shouldn't be allowed to ...
17 voted, 6 comments
People who are carriers of recessive genetic diseases should not be permitted ...
13 voted, 4 comments
Skin color is a genetic disposition.
12 voted, 3 comments
Genetic engineering should be offered to people who suffer, or whose future ...
4 voted, 3 comments
Many people are afraid of Genetic modification
57 voted, 2 comments

 
   © 2008 Minekey
About     Blog     Terms     Community Guidelines     Privacy    Help    
Online Discussion    Discussion Forum    Discussion Board    Discussion Topics    Opinion Poll    People Index    Topics Index